Is a Medical Assistant Better Than a CNA?

Considering a career in the medical field? You may be wondering if you should become a Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA) or a medical assistant (MA). Both positions have their pros and cons, but which one is better?

Checkout this video:

The duties of a medical assistant vs. a CNA

Medical assistants and certified nurse assistants (CNAs) are two of the most common types of health care support workers. Both jobs involve working closely with patients, providing them with basic care and helping them with daily activities. But what exactly are the differences between these two roles? Let’s take a closer look.

Medical assistants have a more varied job than CNAs. In addition to the basic patient care duties that CNAs perform, Medical Assistants also perform administrative tasks such as scheduling appointments and handling billing and insurance paperwork. They may also be responsible for taking patients’ vital signs, giving injections, and performing basic lab tests. Because they have a more diverse set of responsibilities, medical assistants usually need to complete a formal training program after high school.

CNAs, on the other hand, primarily provide hands-on care to patients. This can include tasks such as bathing and dressing patients, helping them eat and use the bathroom, and moving them around in their beds. CNAs may also monitor patients’ vital signs and provide emotional support. Although CNAs do not need to complete a formal training program, they must pass a state-level certification exam before they can begin working.

The education and training required for a medical assistant vs. a CNA

medical assistants and certified nurse assistants (CNAs) are both important members of the healthcare team. They both provide basic patient care and administrative support, but there are some key differences in their education, training, and scope of practice.

Medical assistants must complete an accredited medical assisting program, which typically takes one to two years. This program includes both classroom and clinical instruction in Medical Terminology anatomy and physiology, patient care, medical office procedures, and more. Upon completion of their training, medical assistants must pass a national certification exam to earn the Certified Medical Assistant (CMA) credential.

In contrast, CNAs only need to complete a brief training program, which can be as short as eight weeks. This program covers basic topics such as infection control, safety measures, and providing personal care to patients. CNAs are not required to take a national certification exam but may need to pass a state-specific competency exam before they can begin working.

Both medical assistants and CNAs perform similar tasks such as taking vital signs, measuring patients’ height and weight, charting patients’ medical histories, and providing emotional support. However, medical assistants have a more expanded scope of practice and can perform additional duties such as administering injections, handling lab specimens, and performing basic diagnostic tests.

The job outlook for medical assistants vs. CNAs

The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) anticipates that medical assistant jobs will grow by 29% from 2016 to 2026. The median annual salary for medical assistants was $31,540 in 2017, although earnings can vary significantly depending on experience, employer and geographic region.

In contrast, the job outlook for CNAs is expected to grow by only 11% from 2016 to 2026 according to the BLS. The median annual salary for CNAs was $24,020 in 2017. However, it’s important to note that many CNAs earn a significantly higher wage when working in long-term care facilities or hospitals.

The average salary of a medical assistant vs. a CNA

The average salary of a medical assistant is $15 per hour, while the average salary of a CNA is $12 per hour. While both salaries vary depending on experience and location, medical assistants generally make more than CNAs.

The benefits of being a medical assistant vs. a CNA

There are many benefits to being a medical assistant vs. a CNA. Medical assistants have more responsibilities and earn more money. They also have the opportunity to advance their career by becoming a registered nurse or a licensed practical nurse. CNAs can only work in entry-level positions and do not have the same career prospects as medical assistants.

The drawbacks of being a medical assistant vs. a CNA

There are a few drawbacks of being a medical assistant vs. a CNA. One is that medical assistants generally have more clinical duties than CNAs. This can include taking vitals, drawing blood, and giving injections. As a result, medical assistants often have less time to provide one-on-one care to patients. Another drawback is that medical assistants usually make slightly less money than CNAs. Finally, medical assistants typically have less job security than CNAs since there is always a need for CNAs but the demand for medical assistants can vary depending on the economy.

The best places to work as a medical assistant vs. a CNA

The medical field is a great place to find a career that offers both personal and professional fulfillment. If you’re looking for a job in the medical field, you may be wondering whether you should become a certified nursing assistant (CNA) or a medical assistant (MA). Both jobs have their pros and cons, but in general, MAs have more opportunities for advancement and higher pay than CNAs.

The worst places to work as a medical assistant vs. a CNA

It really depends on the facility that you work at as to whether being a medical assistant or a CNA is better. There are some places that are really great to work at as a medical assistant, and others that are really not so great. The same can be said for CNAs. Here is a list of the worst places to work as a medical assistant vs. a CNA:

-The worst place to work as a medical assistant would have to be a clinic that is understaffed and overworked. This can be very stressful and you will likely not have much time to do your job properly.
-The worst place to work as a CNA would have to be a nursing home that is understaffed and doesn’t pay very well. This can be very stressful and you will likely not have much time to do your job properly.

What type of personality is best suited for a medical assistant vs. a CNA

The type of personality that is best suited for a medical assistant is someone who is detail-oriented, organized, and able to multitask. These individuals need to be able to work well under pressure and be able to juggle multiple tasks at one time. A medical assistant also needs to be able to communicate effectively with patients and their families.

The type of personality that is best suited for a CNA is someone who is compassionate, patient, and has a desire to help others. CNAs need to be able to work closely with patients and have the ability to build rapport easily. These individuals also need to be physically fit as they will be required to lift and move patients.

Which career is better for you: medical assistant or CNA?

There is no simple answer to the question of whether a medical assistant or a CNA is better for you. It depends on your own individual skills, interests, and goals.

Both medical assistants and CNAs perform important roles in healthcare, but they have different duties. Medical assistants generally have more clinical responsibilities, such as taking vital signs, drawing blood, and administering injections. CNAs generally have more direct patient care duties, such as bathing and dressing patients, providing transportation, and serving meals.

If you are interested in a career in healthcare but are unsure which role is right for you, consider shadowing both medical assistants and CNAs to see what their day-to-day tasks involve. You can also talk to healthcare professionals in both roles to get their insights. Ultimately, the best way to decide if a medical assistant or CNA career is better for you is to explore both options and make an informed decision based on your own research.